Resources > Articles > [Guide] How Much Will a Successful Loyalty Program Cost You?

[Guide] How Much Will a Successful Loyalty Program Cost You?

You’ve decided to run a loyalty program and you already have great ideas for every aspect of the customer experience, from rewards to in-store events. But one critical question that all companies face is: How much will the loyalty program cost?

Many of our clients ask our team what kind of costs to expect in a loyalty program so they can better plan according to their budget.

If you’re feeling like cost is a grey area, don’t worry. We’re here for you.

Here is a checklist (with a worksheet, an ebook and a video among other things) to help you begin calculating loyalty-related costs. It’s not all-inclusive, since no two loyalty programs are alike, but it’s a great place to start. I’ll also share some tips for making your plan budget-friendly.

So grab a notepad and a pencil, and let’s get calculating!

#1. [Worksheet] Planning, research and rewards

Let’s start out with a very important point. Having a great loyalty program requires a lot of planning time. This includes:

  • Technical research for loyalty program implementation: You might use a loyalty management platform like Antavo, consult an agency, or create your own program from scratch. In any case, this decision requires time for research and consultation.
  • Preparations to create the loyalty program structure: This includes planning and/or sourcing rewards, determining customer tiers, planning segmentation and scheduling marketing communication.
  • Plan for a post-launch strategy: You’ll also need to invest time in your program after it launches. Plan to spend time on getting customer feedback about the program, and regularly updating your rewards program to keep it fresh.
  • Cost of the reward: It can be a custom product, an event ticket, a VIP service, a product that has been in your inventory for a long time, etc. Each item and experience has a base price – including the time and energy spent with the design team – which needs to be considered.
  • The cost of delivering the reward: If you’re working with physical products, be sure to consider the cost of shipping. You can reduce costs by shipping a reward with the customer’s next purchase.

One of the most important elements of a loyalty program is the rewards (which can include both monetary and experiential rewards). We included a template here, which can help you design your loyalty program reward system. Download it here.

Reward planning worksheet banner

A healthy reward catalog consists of a wide variety of incentives, ranging from general discounts to experiential rewards exclusive to your brand, such as VIP rewards or signed greeting cards.

#2. Technical implementation

To make a loyalty program work, the technical costs generally come in two main categories:

Loyalty platform: Whether you buy third-party plugins, enter into a contract with an expert SaaS loyalty provider, or build your own program, there will be a price tag to consider.

Human resources: If you decide to develop a program yourself, you’ll need a whole development + strategy + management team to make it happen. If you decide to involve a third party, you’ll need to involve the following colleagues in the process:

  1. A project manager on your side to take the lead in key decisions
  2. Some members of your IT team or a development agency you work with, to help with the integration
  3. The actual manager of the loyalty program, who will manage rewards, run campaigns and execute the communication strategy. Most of the time it’s a loyalty or CRM specialist
  4. A loyalty program consultant, who will help build a creative concept design and shed light on best practices in the industry. You can hire a consultant from an agency, but we can also provide the necessary insight at Antavo
  5. If you are using third-party integrations, you’ll also need support from each party’s IT team to seamlessly connect their services
The above implementation flow illustrates the steps required to get your loyalty program on track. Bear in mind that the concept cannot be adjusted in perpetuity, because that would disrupt the execution phase.

The above implementation flow illustrates the steps required to get your loyalty program on track. Bear in mind that the concept cannot be adjusted in perpetuity, because that would disrupt the execution phase.

#3. Promoting your program

Having a loyalty program is one thing, but making it a success story is another. That’s why your advertising budget should also be considered from the very beginning.

  • Arrangements: Come up with design elements and slogans that align with your brand (e.g. visualize customer levels, rewards or activities, and use language that creates a feeling of exclusivity).
  • Campaign launch: Announce your loyalty program launch in a newsletter, run Facebook ads, use retargeting, Google Adwords, or even create a promo video to drive signups.
  • Lifetime management: Send follow-up emails, continue your promotions (advertise new rewards and program additions), run contests, and organize special events, which focus on increasing member engagement.
JD Williams put extra effort into designing their reward subpage to match the tone and color scheme of their online store perfectly.

JD Williams put extra effort into designing their reward subpage to match the tone and color scheme of their online store perfectly.

#4. Program management

After launching your loyalty program, the manager of the loyalty program will have daily and weekly tasks with the loyalty program, and need to think on a longer-term strategy (an area we help clients every 3 months).

  • Run campaigns in the program: If rewards or activities run out or get boring, you’ll need to create new ones based on customer preferences.
  • Analyze the results: Work with your finance team or your loyalty provider’s consultants to understand the results. From there, you can adjust program elements and communication to optimize those results. Antavo’s Customer Success team would help you understand both.
  • Customer support: Answer customer questions and treat your most loyal customers with extra-special care. This principle explains why many fashion brands provide an exclusive customer service line for top-tier customers.
Antavo’s loyalty platform offers a marketer-friendly dashboard that displays reports and analytics in real-time.

Antavo’s loyalty platform offers a marketer-friendly dashboard that displays reports and analytics in real-time.

#5. [Video] Loyalty program ROI

Despite careful preparation, many companies worry about whether they will see a return on their investment. When asked about the topic, I always point out that loyalty programs – when done right – will help your business grow.

Still, ROI is a deep and complicated subject, which is why we decided to discuss it with Jörn Roegler, VP of Strategy & Insight at Antavo, in an episode of Customer Loyalty Minutes. In the episode Jörn pointed out that loyalty programs generate money in several ways: by using loyalty points as a currency, by changing customer behavior, and by teaching you more about your customers. Here are some other highlights from the video:


Expert’s Advice

Knowing the theory behind loyalty program costs is half the victory, but I wanted to give you some practical advice too. And no one’s more knowledgeable about this topic than our brilliant in-house loyalty strategist, Timi Garai.

“Many companies are uneasy when it comes to setting up a loyalty program, as they fear customers will start exploiting the system to pile up free coupons. But if you’ve already distributed free discount vouchers, which didn’t even require customers to make a purchase, then loyalty program discounts are actually an improvement. So let me give you a few pointers on how to avoid the pitfalls many companies fall into.”

Timi Garai
Senior Loyalty Strategist at Antavo

Here are some more tips that Timi shared with us.

  • Create coupons with a minimum spend limit to ensure that loyalty discounts don’t hurt your margins. This value should depend on your margins and product pricing.
  • It’s better to start off strict and adjust the details later, as customers would see it as a sign of good grace on your part.
  • Involve other brands that provide a different product or service as reward providers in your program. It’s free advertisement for them and helps you provide relevant rewards to your customers.
  • Avoid showing open favoritism towards top-tier customers at store locations. Practices such as providing VIP cash registers can brew anger and dissatisfaction among other shoppers.
  • Sweepstakes are alluring and capable of mobilizing every participant within the program, though you only need to give the prize for a handful of lucky winners.
  • Points, credits, or whatever currency you use in your loyalty program are considered to be the most optimal reward for a sweepstake, because customers can spend them on anything their heart desires.
  • Always plan your strategy with care and foresight, as cancelling a fan-favorite loyalty program can lead to backlash from your audience, and your sales will drop, too.

Now everything is under control

Those are the basic costs you should consider when planning your loyalty program. If you would like to consult with an expert on loyalty program budgeting, ROI and optimization, our team is here to help. Book a demo with us to learn more.

If you would like to dig deeper, and learn more about Budget Planning, download our “Budget Planning 101 for Loyalty Programs” ebook.

Budget Planning

Zsuzsa Kecsmar
Zsuzsa Kecsmar
Zsuzsa is CMO and co-founder of Antavo. She manages the marketing team, talks with experts all over the world, holds webinars, and edits all kinds of content (it’s really a lot of editing, but she loves it). She is a mother, likes working out, and making edible cosmetics.