The Secret Ingredient in Succesful Restaurant Loyalty Programs

By analyzing the best fast food and restaurant loyalty programs, you can learn the secret ingredient in a revenue-boosting rewards program.

The cover image of Antavo's restaurant loyalty programs

The fastest way to someone’s heart is through their stomach, right? So it’s no surprise that brands in the food and beverage industry are going gourmet with next-level fast food and restaurant loyalty programs — filling your pocket and belly at the same time.

Consumers love rewards, but most rewards programs aren’t optimized for long-term engagement. Brands at the top of the food chain have designed their loyalty programs with high levels of convenience, plenty of touchpoints and longevity in mind. And to achieve that, they are investing in delivery app solutions where they can easily introduce their programs. Such programs have succeeded in reinforcing brand loyalty with frequent customers and increasing restaurant customer retention through the use of exclusive discounts, VIP access to products, preferential treatment, and more.

Restaurants need to stand out and make their way to the top by providing VIP treatment to their best customers. Nice decor and great cocktails aren’t enough anymore – a true feeling of recognition and appreciation is what they are looking for! A good loyalty program also needs to give restaurants the opportunity to be innovative and different from the competition. It has to offer more value to customers: gamification, rewards, and, most of all, the feeling of being valued and essential to the growth of the brand in which they are choosing to spend their money.

Mathilde Prévost
Alliance Manager at UEAT

Let’s grab a seat at the table with seven companies that are serving up exceptional restaurant loyalty programs for their customers. Bon appétit!

Best Practices for Restaurant Loyalty Programs

A restaurant loyalty program is a type of reward system that’s created to address the needs and requirements of a restaurant or fast-food chain. Restaurant loyalty programs are characterized by:

  • A strong focus on app-based engagement, including digital loyalty cards and receipt scanning
  • Prevalent use of freebies, which are either free food items when customers make a specific number of purchases, or the addition of free extras on special occasions, like birthdays
  • Frequent use of the earn & burn model as the core program structure
  • A reliance on branded merchandise or partner rewards instead of coupons or another financial incentives

Value creation is a substantial facet of the next Restaurant Strategy. Fast-casual and fast food are going to face the biggest opportunities of the last 10 years. And it will involve delivery and take away service! However, people are not looking for discounts. Good food is not a commodity. They want to belong to somewhere, even if it means to purchase more frequently. Loyalty should focus on this sense of belonging.

Domingo Iudice
Co-Founder at Pescaria

1. Dunkin’ Donuts Rewards Program: Priority Service

With over 12,000 shops in 45 countries and over 8 million loyal customers across the globe, Dunkin’ Donuts stores undoubtedly see a lot of traffic each day. Knowing that people hate waiting in long lines, the company utilizes priority services as the main selling point for its restaurant loyalty program, DD Perks.

The most popular use of the membership is placing orders using the company’s app, so customers can instantly claim their orders when they arrive at the store. Loyalty members also earn 5 points per $1 spent and can use the points toward gift cards.

The loyalty program of Dunkin’ Donuts.
Dunkin’ Donuts cleverly designed its app to feature its products in the backdrop, making people hungry just by looking at it — a tactic worth considering when you design your own app.

Dunkin’ Donuts’ rewards program also has a number of clever additions, such as a free birthday gift card. Moreover, thanks to a partnership with Idle-Empire, customers can earn bonus points for playing games and answering survey questions, which is a great source of zero-party data.

Why it works

  • Priority service and early access to upcoming new dishes are not only highly alluring loyalty program features but are also relatively inexpensive.
  • Offering priority service to app users is also a great way to promote an omnichannel experience.
  • Awarding points for activities other than purchases keeps engagement levels high.
  • Using an earn & burn style program does not make a brand stand out, but it does keep the rules simple, which is great for a restaurant’s brand identity.

2. Chipotle Rewards Program: A Diverse Reward Offering

To reward customers in a fresh way, Chipotle ditched the traditional punch card in favor of a fully mobile experience called Chipotle Rewards.

  • The exchange ratio for the loyalty currency: users earn 10 points on their virtual card per $1 spent.
  • New members receive free chips and guacamole after their first purchase.
  • Rewards include free Chipotle orders and branded merchandise.
  • Members of Chipotle Rewards can use the dedicated app to easily reorder their favorite Mexican dish or scan receipts
The loyalty program of Chipotle.
An aspect Chipotle’s rewards program absolutely nails is great app design, which is heavily inspired by the brand’s menu items.

The benefits of being a member of the Chipotle Rewards program don’t end here, as the restaurant has a couple of gamification and surprise & delight elements up its sleeve. For instance, customers can earn various badges by completing challenges and receive a surprise offer on their birthday.

Why it works

  • Chipotle has made multiple kinds of rewards available, from freebies to early access & merchandise.
  • Chipotle has cleverly integrated its mobile app into the reward journey.
  • Badges and birthday rewards are a great way to spice up the experience for customers, at a relatively low cost.

3. Famous Dave’s Rewards Program: App-based Benefits

The award-winning barbeque restaurant Famous Dave’s has a loyalty program that is known for two things: it’s a ribs-themed reward system, and its smartphone app.

  • Every $1 spent equals 1 Bone, which is the program’s currency.
  • Collecting 100 Bones gives customers a $10 discount on their next order.
  • The loyalty program is available on a smartphone app, which also promotes the user’s nearest Famous Dave’s restaurant.
  • Downloading the app gets users a one-time gift: a free burger with the next order.
The Famous Dave’s loyalty program.
The last step to making a mobile integration like Famous Dave’s perfect is to allow customers to pay and earn points directly through their phones.

Famous Dave’s restaurant loyalty program uses more than just rewards to build a loyal follower base, however. The company stays in touch with its members, telling them about the latest updates or offers in a personalized way. This is extremely good way to build a like-minded community and show that being close to the brand is more than just food and rewards.

Why it works

  • Famous Dave’s loyalty program is simple and easy to understand.
  • The app can be used for identification in the store.
  • The brand engages in personalized communication with its members.

4. Chick-fil-A Rewards Program: Tiers & Experiential Rewards

As the originator of the classic, pickle-topped chicken sandwich, Chick-fil-A needed a loyalty program to match its image. It pretty much sums up all the neat little features we listed above: loyalty points that can be exchanged for free meals, birthday rewards, and an app that handles both orders and the loyalty currency.

However, Chick-fil-A One goes even further by implementing some truly next-gen restaurant loyalty program elements. The most notable is their tier system: by default, customers earn 10 points per dollar spent, but reaching higher levels increases the points-per-dollar ratio up to 13.

The loyalty program of Chick-fil-A.
The fact that Chick-fil-A increases the amount of points members earn per dollar spent means it takes less time for top-level members to earn a free meal.

Higher Chick-fil-A membership levels also unlock better rewards, including access to the backstage tours at the Chick-fil-A Home Office and the ability to share the rewards with friends and family members. Overall, a higher tier means a better experience for members.

Why it works

  • Chick-fil-A offers a highly engaging and long-term loyalty program thanks to its tiered system.
  • The program provides everything customers have come to expect from a restaurant loyalty program, in one attractive package.
  • The program even offers some experiential rewards, like the backstage Home Office tour.

5. La Cage Rewards Program: Rewarding Sport Fans

Canadian sports restaurant chain La Cage revamped its Club Cage loyalty program to focus on rewarding customers beyond dining. Its new loyalty program — powered by Antavo — is now available in 52 restaurants run by the company.

  • Customers earn 10 points for every dollar spent at La Cage’s restaurants or on home delivery.
  • Members can also earn points by referring friends and completing their customer profiles.
  • Loyalty members can use their points to pay for purchases and claim rewards.
The La Cage loyalty program.
Reaching a higher tier at Club Cage boosts the number of points members earn with each purchase, incentivizing customers to return to La Cage as often as possible.

One key highlight of La Cage’s loyalty program is its free wings deal. Being a sports bar through and through, the company runs a long-standing promotionin which, when the Montreal Canadiens score 5 goals, members receive 8 free wings with a $15 purchase.

Why it works

  • Club Cage follows the next-gen restaurant loyalty program model, where higher tiers increase the number of points earned with purchases.
  • La Cage rewards friend referrals to build a larger community.
  • The free wings offer aligns the brand with hockey fans, and makes the restaurants a must-visit during matches.

6. McDonald’s Rewards Program: Freebies Galore

The MyMcDonald’s Rewards program is a fan-favorite of many generations, and for a good reason: it doesn’t shy away from handing out free meals to members just to create a bond with them. It’s also very straightforward, sparing customers from complicated rules and systems.

With each eligible purchase, members receive 100 points for every $1 spent. Points can be redeemed for free treats at specific milestones. For example, 1500 points can be traded in for a cheeseburger, 3000 points are worth a 6-piece chicken nugget, a Happy Meal costs 6000 points, etc.

The loyalty program of McDonald’s.
McDonald’s relies heavily on its app to connect with customers.

MyMcDonald’s magic lies in its many ‘firsts’. Members receive free McNuggets for the first time after downloading the app. Then after making their first purchase as a loyalty program member, they receive 1500 points, which instantly qualifies them for another freebie.

Why it works

  • McDonald’s reward system is easy to understand, easy to use, and everyone can find value in it.
  • The program encourages members to download and use the app.
  • There are plenty of freebies to boost enrollment rates.

7. Red Lobster Rewards Program: Partnership Benefits

Specializing in seafood, Red Lobster is an American casual dining restaurant chain with over 700 restaurants worldwide, including the US, Canada, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Mexico, and Japan. As such, the My Red Lobster Rewards program has a lot of expectations to live up to.

  • Members spend $1 to earn one point. After every 125 points, members can choose from three different freebies for their order.
  • New members earn 75 points when they enroll.
  • There are three tiers in total, with benefits like free birthday gifts,  double points for to-go orders, early access, and unlimited games on in-restaurant tabletop devices.
he loyalty program at Red Lobster.
The Red Lobster Rewards loyalty program has plenty of tiered benefits, which push members to visit more, so they can level up.

My Red Lobster Rewards also hosts a range of limited-time partner offers. For instance, members can earn 10¢ per gallon up to 20 gallons at Shell for every $50 in qualified purchases at Red Lobster. Such deals make membership even more valuable.

Why it works

  • My Red Lobsters Rewards has a tier system with a great range of rewards, ensuring long-term customer engagement.
  • Some of the rewards in the loyalty program promote restaurant visits, which are more memorable than online orders.
  • Cross-brand offers increase the value of being an active member.

The Last Bite

Restaurant loyalty programs are superb assets for food industry leaders who want to drive repeat purchases and increase engagement. Just remember: you can go either super streamlined, focusing on freebies and hassle-free experience (backed up by a strong focus on mobile), or an incremental progression where tiers influence how many points members earn for their purchase, coupled with plenty of level-specific benefits.

If you’re interested, Antavo can help you create a loyalty program custom-tailored to your brand’s identity. Simply contact us, or send us an RFP. Also, check out one of our comprehensive guides about food & beverage loyalty programs.

And don’t forget to download Antavo’s Customer Loyalty Report 2022, an in-depth report that showcases dozens of statistics as well as future industry trends to help you navigate the world of next-gen loyalty programs.

A banner recommending to download Antavo’s Global Customer Loyalty Report 2022.

Headshot of Timi Garai Senior Business Analyst at Antavo

Timi Garai

Timi is a Senior Business Analyst at Antavo. She has helped numerous eCommerce, physical retailers and B2C brands strengthen customer loyalty, and significantly increase annual revenue. Timi is also the head organizer of one of the largest anime conventions in Europe.

You might also like

The cover image of Antavo's Food And Beverage Loyalty Programs Guide
Guides by Andy Nemes • January 14, 2022 • 18 min read

Loyalty Programs in Grocery & Food and Beverage: A Comprehensive Guide (2022)

A deep dive into the world of food & beverage and grocery loyalty programs, sharing key trends and best practices in the 21st century.

Reviews by Tamas Oszi • July 15, 2022 • 7 min read

Kellogg’s Rewards Program Review: It’s Grrreat!

We dive deep into the world of loyalty programs and analyze the strengths and weaknesses of Kellogg’s rewards program, the Kellogg’s Family Rewards

The cover image of Antavo's Tiered Loyalty Programs article.
Guides by Zsuzsa Kecsmar • April 7, 2022 • 17 min read

Why Tiered Loyalty Programs Are So Attractive to Customers

How to create successful tiered loyalty programs: see our best practices and 7 real-life examples of brands who have done an amazing job.

Partners who trust us
Logo line of partners working together with Antavo. Logo line of partners working together with Antavo.


Antavo's listing in Gartner.
Antavo's inclusion in Forrester.