The Roots of Customer Loyalty And Its Secret Link to Loyalty Programs

Prioritizing and building customer loyalty for long-term survival is a must for businesses. Find out how to do it right with our help.

Antavo’s cover for its article about customer loyalty

“Customer loyalty” is one of those industry terms that needs no introduction. We all know what it means, we’ve heard it a thousand times in CRM meetings and seen it among the company KPIs. It’s the yellow-brick road that leads to customer retention. Yet occasionally it’s worth taking a step back and re-evaluating the things we take for granted. How does customer loyalty really work, and how can it be inspired? Is it based on rational or emotional decisions? Is it simply habit-building? And how does a loyalty program tie into it? Well, keep reading to find out!

If you’re interested in an in-depth look at how customer loyalty is reflected in the current loyalty program landscape, make sure to check out our Global Customer Loyalty Report.

A banner recommending to download Antavo’s Global Customer Loyalty Report 2024.

The Definition of Customer Loyalty – A Mutually Beneficial Agreement

When talking about loyalty, it is crucial to differentiate between personal loyalty (between friends and family members) and customer loyalty (between an individual and a business). The two have a few things in common, for example, they’re both earned by actions and developed over time. Still, there are several reasons as to why they’re fundamentally different. The most important differences are the nature of how loyalty is earned, and the actions by which it manifests. 

In our personal lives, forging bonds has no financial connotation. You don’t earn points for giving advice to your friends, or helping out a family member: it is purely out of genuine connection and kindness. In a commercial/business setting, however, both earning and acting on loyalty are tied to a (transactional or non-transactional) benefit-based system — the best example of this is a loyalty program

Icon for the "Infoblock" section of Antavo's article.

Customer loyalty is a customer’s recurring behavior, that has a commercial benefit for your brand. It includes repeat purchases, preference over competitors, brand advocacy, social engagement, and loyalty program engagement. Customer loyalty is earned through outstanding customer service, high product quality, added benefits, and loyalty program systems.

5 Reasons Why Customer Loyalty Is Important – Start Taking Notes 

Customer loyalty manifests in quite a few beneficial ways for a brand. Here are some highlights as to how it can improve your business:   

  1. Keeping a loyal customer costs far less: As we know, it is much less financially straining to regain a customer than to acquire a new one. In fact, successfully bringing in a new customer costs as much as 7x more than retaining an existing customer.
  2. A first good impression will lead to return visits: It is much easier to convince someone who once purchased from you (and walked away with a great impression) to come back, than to convince someone who has never heard of or tried your products. Return visits are more likely from customers who are already familiar with your experience, quality, and value. 
  3. You will always be their first choice: A happy and satisfied customer who enjoys their loyalty benefits will automatically seek out your products (in-store or online) when they require refills or similar items, so there is far less risk of losing sales to your competitors.
  4. Long, profitable years together: A nurtured loyal customer generates much higher revenue for a longer period than a shopper with no loyalties or incentives to purchase again.
  5. Good PR is the Best PR: Organic recommendations have enormous swaying power in today’s distrustful society. Happy customers are prone to relay positive experiences to their social circles and online communities, bringing in more potential buyers and revenue for the company.
Customer loyalty is a valuable currency for brands.
Customer loyalty is a key currency for brands to cherish and nourish over time. The connection manifests both in terms of finances and public relations.

The Difference Between Surface-Level and Real Customer Loyalty

In the world of customer retention, it’s important to know that customers who are easy to attract may also be easy to lose. In the current financially unstable environment, customers and companies alike think twice about what they are spending on. 

To ensure high ROI, companies need to look for long-term returns, aka true customer loyalty, instead of encouraging short-term, one-time buy-in. Trying to “buy” loyalty with price cuts and coupons essentially teaches consumers to be dependent on special deals. The moment the benefits stop or a competitor offers better deals, those customers will leave you in the dust. You are essentially just buying a temporary audience, which won’t drive your KPIs in the long run. 

Exclusively targeting price-sensitive shoppers will never result in a truly loyal audience. This is precisely why systems like loyalty programs are more beneficial: they gradually build trust and shape customer behavior.

When it comes to customer loyalty, it is crucial to build trust and create a genuine connection that will last over time, regardless of outside circumstances and price adjustments.

How Do You Identify a Loyal Customer? – Actions Speak Loud and Clear

The requirements for customer loyalty change for every business. After all, a loyal customer’s purchase frequency for a luxury fashion brand differs completely from that of a fast food chain. So, instead of relying on a magic formula, think about what actions you want your loyal customers to take. There are actions that need to be analyzed from both a financial and emotional standpoint:

Financial dedication:

  • Spending with the one and only: Your loyal customers purchase exclusively (or at least overwhelmingly) from you in the product categories you offer.
  • Keep coming back for more: Purchase frequency is just as important as average basket value. The more shoppers repeatedly shop with you, the more connected, dedicated, and loyal they are.
  • Go above and beyond: In a transactional sense, your most loyal customers are those willing to stay with you through (rational) price increases — and opt into your premium offerings as well.

Emotional commitment:

  • They really like you: When customers take action, like leaving great reviews and social recommendations, it showcases genuine love for your brand.
  • Forgiveness is a virtue: Shoppers who are truly dedicated to your brand will allow you more leeway for making mistakes than others. (On the condition that you show that you’re growing and learning from their feedback.)
  • It all comes down to trust: Your most loyal customers will be more likely to trust you with their data, will be more willing to fill out surveys and complete quizzes, and will provide more zero-party information in general.
A mockup of Antavo’s gamified profiling module, showing three different screens.
Customers who love you are more likely to trust you with their personal data or show a willingness to answer a survey honestly. Still, offering some rewards for doing so can be an additional motivator. 

The Evolution of Customer Loyalty – Stairway to Loyalty Heaven

1. First-Time Delight

This segment represents the group of customers, who are delighted with the first purchase experience. They were impressed by the ease of access, product range, variety in color/size, in-store assistance/online chatbot, multiple payment methods, shipping, overall cost, timely arrival, and follow-up care from the company. Thanks to the positive contact, they are inclined to seek out the company again in the future.

2. Going back for Seconds

After a first positive experience that exceeds expectations, satisfied customers will remember your company. Next time, instead of a generic search, they will go straight to your website or store to search for a similar product. If they are happy with the results again, they will be more and more inclined to do more than just buy your products. They may, for example, download your smartphone app, subscribe to your newsletter, or register for your loyalty program.

Ray-Ban’s loyalty program The Ones offers exclusive early access to members. 
Ray-Ban rewards loyal customers, who sign up for their loyalty program called: The Ones by offering exclusive access to limited collections, and members-only fan experiences. 

3. Engaging With the Loyalty Program

This is where you take things to a more organized level. Now that you hold the customer’s attention, it’s time to start building that ever-important emotional connection.  Through habit building via a loyalty program. This could happen by involving your customers in a reward program, engaging them in fun games and activities in,- and outside of the buying cycle. It’s important to start setting goals and milestones they can achieve (granting a sense of fulfillment upon completion) because this will continue to power the positive experience and keep them coming back for more.

4. Becoming an Ambassador

At this point, your customer has made repeat purchases, they’re signed into your loyalty program, they are engaged and connected, and they are happy with their experience. And what do happy people do? They spread the word about your business, effectively becoming your advocates and brand ambassadors. To achieve this, you need to ensure a seamless and satisfying experience from the moment they come across your products, through the buying process, all the way to a fresh and engaging loyalty program.

Charlotte Tilbury’s program is built on constantly engaging fans with fun rewards.
Charlotte’s Loyalty Programme is one of the most beloved customer rewards programs in the beauty community. By offering points for non-transactional actions, the brand keeps loyal members engaged and entertained.

Where the Loyalty Program Vision Starts – Everything Is Possible With the Right Ingredients

Building customer loyalty is like fine dining. A lot of responsibly sourced, top-of-the-line ingredients are combined in just the right way, at the right time, and in the right format. Excellent service and high product quality represent the basics; a clever loyalty program with a well-thought-out reward system embodies the artful flavoring that keeps customers coming back.

In short, a loyalty program is a marketing tool that helps businesses shape customer behavior and establishes long-term engagement that prevents them from switching to the competition. This is done through monetary rewards, personalized content, special privileges, and lifestyle-driven experiences.

Lifestyle-driven elements are engaging features in modern loyalty programs.
One of the most engaging ways to build customer loyalty is through lifestyle-driven elements, both on the earning and spending sides of the program.

How to Build Customer Loyalty – Skyrocketing Loyalty With Rational and Emotional Rewards 

In the past, loyalty programs were all about coupons, discounts, and stamp collection. However, modern loyalty programs have gone beyond that because organizations have realized that loyalty cannot be bought with vouchers. That’s why next-gen loyalty programs also include emotional features that make the experience more personalized and memorable. 

 Rational loyalty program elements include:

  • Earn & burn point logic 
  • Coupons & vouchers
  • Cashback offers
  • Members-only discounts
  • Free shipping as a perk
  • Instant gratification, like welcome rewards
  • Earning opportunities at partners
  • Cross-brand benefits

Emotional loyalty program elements include: 

  • Personalized product recommendations
  • Gamification, like prize wheels or prize draws
  • Badges and challenges
  • Experiential benefits, such as invites to an anniversary party
  • Branded merch or items signed by an influencer
  • Privileges, like access to VIP customer service
  • Surprise & delight email campaigns
  • Opportunities to earn rewards via non-transactional means, e.g., writing product reviews, bringing back used clothes, or living an active life
Icon for the "Infoblock" section of Antavo's article.

Remember, a smart loyalty program uses both types of elements at the same. Although rational incentives motivate people to become program members, the emotional elements transform them into loyal customers.

Creating a loyalty program where the rational and emotional sides come together in perfect harmony ensures higher engagement, more loyalty points spent, and improved retention rates, like in Rip Curl’s case

Customer Loyalty Is Invaluable – Make Sure to Treat It That Way

Ensuring your customers’ happiness goes a long way towards enabling a lasting connection and true loyalty. Trust and commitment aren’t freely given — they need to be earned. But they can just as easily be lost! Make sure that you’re always providing value for your customers through your products, the buying experience, and your loyalty program.

Establishing customer loyalty through habit building via loyalty program engagement will provide longevity and vitality to your business. And that’s the most valuable currency you can have.

To learn more about loyalty programs and explore creative and engaging features, please make sure to book a demo or include Antavo in your RFP process.

If you haven’t already, make sure to also download our Global Customer Loyalty Report for the latest insights and expert predictions.

A banner recommending to download Antavo’s Global Customer Loyalty Report 2024.
Headshot of Zsuzsa Kecsmar, Co-founder, CMO and Head of Partnerships at Antavo

Zsuzsa Kecsmar

Zsuzsa is the Chief Strategy Officer & Co-founder of Antavo. She has experienced Antavo grow from a startup into a scaleup. Listed by Forbes as one of Europe’s top 100 female founders in tech, Zsuzsa is a former journalist recognized by the European Commission.

You might also like

Articles by Timi Garai • April 15, 2021 • 8 min read

How to Enhance Lifecycle Marketing With Loyalty Programs

Struggling to maintain interest across your customer journey? Learn how to fuel your customer lifecycle marketing with a next-gen loyalty program!

The cover for Antavo’s article about the Rip Curl membership program.
Articles by Barbara Kekes-Szabo • February 16, 2023 • 5 min read

Club Rip Curl: A Membership Program That Rewards Surfing

Learn everything there is to know about Rip Curl’s lifestyle membership program built around passion and inclusivity.

Antavo’s cover image for its definitive guide about customer loyalty programs.
Guides by Tamas Oszi • March 19, 2024 • 98 min read

Customer Loyalty Programs: A Definitive Guide With 13 Actionable Steps

Antavo’s definitive guide on customer loyalty programs shows you what to focus on in order to create a high-performing rewards program.